A Glorious New Chapter In Nonprofit Evaluation

By Heidi Genrich

My entire holiday season was made on December 1st, 2009 when Charity Navigator, GiveWell, Great Nonprofits, Guidestar and Philanthropedia issued a joint press release condemning  the use of overhead ratios and executive salaries to evaluate nonprofits.

Judging a nonprofit’s quality by how much they spend on laser printers vs. African wells, arbitrarily creating universal budget guidelines for all types of organizations, always seemed a little silly. Even if the overhead-ratio-executive-salary method of comparing nonprofits worked in specific circumstances, it made no attempt to measure the actual impact of their programs.

Tim Ogden put the problem best in his post on Philanthropy Action:

In short, picking a charity based on the lowest overhead ratio is like buying the cheapest car that money can buy. You might spend less in the short run but it’s inevitably going to let you down.

Ken Berger, the CEO and President of Charity Navigator, may have sent the biggest waves through the nonprofit community with his statement that “too many donors are paying too much attention to measures like overhead.” Charity Navigator became the web’s nonprofit gold standard precisely because it encouraged donors to judge and compare nonprofits based on their overhead ratios. This is a turning point that is long overdue.

As a longtime critic of overhead ratio evaluations, Dan Pallota’s post on the press release may be the most interesting. The next step is to figure out an accessible standard by which the average donor can evaluate the >1 million nonprofit organizations in the US.


One response to “A Glorious New Chapter In Nonprofit Evaluation

  1. Pingback: Guidestar Launches A Nonprofit Rating Platform « Causecast Nonprofit

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s